5 Comments
User's avatar
Donald Clarke's avatar

Thanks for posting. These are heartbreaking stories.

eben Homeys's avatar

“I use chatGPT and here is what they said”

yikes. Thanks for the heads up though! Muted forever

Khải Đơn's avatar

Thank you for posting. I find the juxtaposition of the letter 2 and 3 kind of interesting. While in the 2nd letter, the writer complains about their parents' constant hard work for the harvest and for their home, the 3rd letter does not find the meaning in the repeating grind of the gig economy. Maybe the 2nd letter can be the response for the 3rd letter, meaning of work and life stays with the older people in the 2nd letter because they are in touch with their land, harvest, home and life. They keep their agency at every step of it. While working as a food dilvery worker strips their agency off, they don't have any rights, they don't own the result of work, and they don't see how their new days look.

John B Turner's avatar

Outstanding journalism dealing with serious aspects of real life for probably the majority of people in China. I came to China so as to understand the country my friend and colleague Tom Hutchins (1921-2007) photographed in 1956 and wasn't allowed to return. A New Zealander, like me, his (rare) 6-month visa was cut to four for, he surmised "asking too many questions" at the time. I can't speak or read mandarin, unfortunately, and am nearing the end of my life, as a photographer and writer, but having cherished the idea of contact with some of the people Tom photographed, my Chinese wife claims that her people would not be interested in seeing Tom's pictures of them. My view is the opposite. Any way, if possible, I would like to contact the photographer whose story is recounted in this magnificent journalism, to share and perhaps help him in some way. My Wechat is JohnBTurnerNZ and I live in Gaobeidian, Hebei.

The Freeze-Frame Revolution's avatar

The farmer couple from Yulin, Shaanxi Province are the freer of the lot. They give the order and they execute, they are masters over their own domain and time and they grow their own food. And being the younger farmers in their comunity, they do have standing. They know that as long they are kicking, they are alive. Spending time outside in the hills is not necessarily doing gruelling work. Probably 8-10 hours in a factory on some assembly work is more taxing, more numbing and creates much more mental and physical health problems than the life of this couple. The son/daughter has an ankle deep understanding of life and probably the parents are pithying him/her...