I think we need to get away from thinking that progress either occurs top down through central planning or bottom up through competitive markets. It occurs through a process of “coordinated adaptation”, where central authorities engage with independent agents to coordinate public and private investments. We need both top down coordination and bottom up adaptation.
I agree with this statement. "Put differently, a power structure that allows and encourages competing policy proposals is an essential institutional safeguard for sound public policy. Such a structure must necessarily be pluralistic. Policymaking cannot depend excessively on political authority at the top. Such a political order must be reformed and a polycentric policymaking system established."
My special interest is the means by which public policy can be changed to ensure that the structure of the family is strengthened so that it can look after its sick, disabled and unemployed rather than requiring a subsidy from government by way of social services that, in western economies tends to become beholden to special interest groups interested in securing their own ends. eg the medical industrial complex. The recipients of social services are can live independently of the family and can become irresponsible. They lack supervision and are unlikely to make a contribution according to their capacity.
To have strong families they must own their place of residence. rather than be subject to landlord exploitation. State owned housing can also be a disaster.
To secure that end a raft of changes need to be made. To shift the stance of a monolithic central organization is a massive task that is likely to take generations unless the system breaks down due to a crisis, perhaps due to debt made necessary by the social service burden or military adventurism, or challenges from without. France is a current example. The Government is responsible for nearly 60% of the GNP via the combination of taxation and irresponsible borrowing. It's not alone in that respect.
Government at the local level has the potential to adapt if it has the ability to experiment, if it has an independent source of finance and if its driven by observation of what works. Unfortunately, in western societies this is not possible because so much is determined from the centre and so little locally. There can be a lot of rigidity locally, if people like town planners have the structure and rules handed down from a central authority and if the bureaucracy is promoted from within an ossified pool of talent not subject to cross fertilization from those who work in the market economy.
A structure that promotes its civil servants based on their performance in local jurisdictions to a provincial or state level and then to the central level, and where there is flexibility at the local level to try new things and if they are successful, to implement them more widely has a tremendous advantage. The closer the decision maker is to the people affected by that decision, the greater the chance of effective feedback. That's why its so important to encourage consultative arrangements at the local level, call it democracy if you want, and for the centre not to think that central planning is the only way forward.
The 'mayor economy' has a great advantage, and of course the possibility of corruption. That's a risk you have to take to achieve fast progress. If the mayor is also an entrepreneur, has a seat on the board of a local productive enterprise and shares in the task of enabling a local employer to succeed, cross fertilization is possible. A great example is CXMT the memory chip maker.
What strikes me is who is saying it. A man who sat inside the rural policy apparatus in the 1980s is arguing that the reform era's founding success came from below, from competition between approaches, not from design at the top. That reads differently today, when top-level design is the official vocabulary.
My question is practical. The experimentation Zhao describes rode on real local room, including fiscal room. Land sales revenue has roughly halved from its 2021 peak. Where does a province now find the space to try something different?
China’s rural reform followed Deng Xiaoping’s famous dictum, “Cross the river by feeling the stones,” embodying a pragmatic approach that emphasized proceeding step by step, learning from experience, and adjusting course as needed rather than blindly following a rigid ideology or predetermined blueprint.
"The decision-making process behind rural reform also shows that public policy cannot be scientifically engineered." Maybe not scientifically engineered, but rural reform can be scientifically determined. Science is experimentation to see what works. That's what the government seems to have done. Marxism, at root, is basing decisions on material reality. Theory or standardization follows. No master plan? Central plans are basically targets. The broad target is obvious: efficient production without gross inequality of benefits. There is no contradiction with Party ideology. As for 1958, different times and circumstances require different methodologies. The notion of continuous change and adaptation is fundamental to Marxism--in spite of the grotesque caricatures common in the West. Which is why China is beating the pants off of the US, stuck in the mythology of laissez-faire capitalism.
I think we need to get away from thinking that progress either occurs top down through central planning or bottom up through competitive markets. It occurs through a process of “coordinated adaptation”, where central authorities engage with independent agents to coordinate public and private investments. We need both top down coordination and bottom up adaptation.
I agree with this statement. "Put differently, a power structure that allows and encourages competing policy proposals is an essential institutional safeguard for sound public policy. Such a structure must necessarily be pluralistic. Policymaking cannot depend excessively on political authority at the top. Such a political order must be reformed and a polycentric policymaking system established."
My special interest is the means by which public policy can be changed to ensure that the structure of the family is strengthened so that it can look after its sick, disabled and unemployed rather than requiring a subsidy from government by way of social services that, in western economies tends to become beholden to special interest groups interested in securing their own ends. eg the medical industrial complex. The recipients of social services are can live independently of the family and can become irresponsible. They lack supervision and are unlikely to make a contribution according to their capacity.
To have strong families they must own their place of residence. rather than be subject to landlord exploitation. State owned housing can also be a disaster.
To secure that end a raft of changes need to be made. To shift the stance of a monolithic central organization is a massive task that is likely to take generations unless the system breaks down due to a crisis, perhaps due to debt made necessary by the social service burden or military adventurism, or challenges from without. France is a current example. The Government is responsible for nearly 60% of the GNP via the combination of taxation and irresponsible borrowing. It's not alone in that respect.
Government at the local level has the potential to adapt if it has the ability to experiment, if it has an independent source of finance and if its driven by observation of what works. Unfortunately, in western societies this is not possible because so much is determined from the centre and so little locally. There can be a lot of rigidity locally, if people like town planners have the structure and rules handed down from a central authority and if the bureaucracy is promoted from within an ossified pool of talent not subject to cross fertilization from those who work in the market economy.
A structure that promotes its civil servants based on their performance in local jurisdictions to a provincial or state level and then to the central level, and where there is flexibility at the local level to try new things and if they are successful, to implement them more widely has a tremendous advantage. The closer the decision maker is to the people affected by that decision, the greater the chance of effective feedback. That's why its so important to encourage consultative arrangements at the local level, call it democracy if you want, and for the centre not to think that central planning is the only way forward.
The 'mayor economy' has a great advantage, and of course the possibility of corruption. That's a risk you have to take to achieve fast progress. If the mayor is also an entrepreneur, has a seat on the board of a local productive enterprise and shares in the task of enabling a local employer to succeed, cross fertilization is possible. A great example is CXMT the memory chip maker.
Good to have this in English.
What strikes me is who is saying it. A man who sat inside the rural policy apparatus in the 1980s is arguing that the reform era's founding success came from below, from competition between approaches, not from design at the top. That reads differently today, when top-level design is the official vocabulary.
My question is practical. The experimentation Zhao describes rode on real local room, including fiscal room. Land sales revenue has roughly halved from its 2021 peak. Where does a province now find the space to try something different?
China’s rural reform followed Deng Xiaoping’s famous dictum, “Cross the river by feeling the stones,” embodying a pragmatic approach that emphasized proceeding step by step, learning from experience, and adjusting course as needed rather than blindly following a rigid ideology or predetermined blueprint.
"The decision-making process behind rural reform also shows that public policy cannot be scientifically engineered." Maybe not scientifically engineered, but rural reform can be scientifically determined. Science is experimentation to see what works. That's what the government seems to have done. Marxism, at root, is basing decisions on material reality. Theory or standardization follows. No master plan? Central plans are basically targets. The broad target is obvious: efficient production without gross inequality of benefits. There is no contradiction with Party ideology. As for 1958, different times and circumstances require different methodologies. The notion of continuous change and adaptation is fundamental to Marxism--in spite of the grotesque caricatures common in the West. Which is why China is beating the pants off of the US, stuck in the mythology of laissez-faire capitalism.